What I Learned After a Month with GPT‑5: Brilliance and Trade‑offs

Published: 2025-08-21

A hands-on review of GPT‑5. While it shows remarkable progress in code generation, it also reveals unexpected drawbacks for natural writing. Why picking the right LLM for each use case matters.

What I Learned After a Month with GPT‑5: Brilliance and Trade‑offs

After using GPT‑5 continuously since release, I found a few things that differ from the common buzz. This post shares a candid review based on real usage.

First Impressions: Better Than Expected

Dramatically Faster

My first impression was the speed. Response latency is clearly improved compared to previous models.

Big Leap in Code Generation

Where I felt the biggest impact was code generation.

I had primarily used Claude for coding, but after trying GPT‑5 I noticed:

  • More accurate code output
  • Better understanding of complex logic
  • Higher-quality error handling

It’s a clear step up. As a coding assistant, it’s among the best right now.

What Emerged with Ongoing Use

Subtle Friction in Writing

However, after a full month of daily use, I made an unexpected decision.

For writing and content generation, I decided not to use GPT‑5 as my main model among OpenAI’s options. In practice, I now mix and match models from multiple vendors rather than relying solely on OpenAI.

GPT‑5’s “Too Smart” Problem

Complexity from Information Overload

GPT‑5 is definitely smarter. At times, though, that strength becomes a weakness:

  • Tendency to cram in every possible detail
  • Outputs become more complex than necessary
  • Overly elaborate explanations when a simple answer is wanted

Less Natural Tone

As many users point out, GPT‑5 can feel a bit cold.

In short, its intelligence sometimes comes at the cost of natural conversational feel.

Why Choosing the Right LLM Matters

What I learned: higher capability doesn’t mean one model fits all use cases.

Where GPT‑5 shines:

  • Code generation and debugging
  • Solving complex technical problems
  • Tasks that require deep analysis

Where other models may fit better:

  • Natural, human-like writing
  • Casual conversation
  • Creative writing

Takeaway: Fit the Tool to the Task

GPT‑5 is a real advancement, but it’s not the best choice for every scenario.

Understanding each LLM’s strengths and matching them to the job is the key to effective AI use.

« Back to Blog